Employee Benefits Client Manager & Department Leader Orlando

Orlando , FL $90,000.00 - $140,000.00 / Annual

Description

Employee Benefits Client Manager & Department Leader
An established and highly regarded independent insurance agency in Central Florida is seeking an experienced Employee Benefits Account Manager/Leader to manage a book of business and lead its Employee Benefits service team.
This is a hands-on leadership role for someone who enjoys managing client relationships, overseeing daily operations, improving workflows, and developing a strong service team. The ideal candidate will balance client management responsibilities with team leadership, ensuring the department operates efficiently while delivering excellent service to clients.

Key Responsibilities
Manage and oversee an Employee Benefits book of business, maintaining strong client relationships and ensuring quality service.

Lead and manage the day-to-day activities, workload, and priorities of the EB service team.

Oversee workflows, processes, and technology to improve department efficiency.

Handle escalated client service issues and provide guidance and support to the team.

Assist with recruiting, hiring, onboarding, and training new team members.

Provide ongoing coaching, mentoring, and professional development for EB staff.

Help establish service standards, improve processes, and support the continued growth of the department.


Qualifications
5–7+ years of Employee Benefits experience.

Experience working within an independent insurance agency in an Employee Benefits role.

1–2 years of supervisory or leadership experience, or demonstrated readiness to step into a leadership position.

Strong organizational and communication skills.

Ability to manage competing priorities, oversee workflows, and resolve day-to-day challenges.

A hands-on leadership style with the ability to mentor, motivate, and develop a team.


About Criterion Executive Search, Inc.

For 45 years Criterion Executive Search has been recognized as one of the nation’s leading executive staffing and recruiting firms. As one of Tampa, FL first recruiting & staffing agencies we have been privileged to work with leading companies throughout the state of Florida. Those same strategic partnerships have allowed us to perfect our personalized, life-cycle approach to placing the ideal candidates with their ideal companies.

Our innovative individualized placement strategies allow us to match Insurance professionals with companies throughout the country, and beyond. Each of our job placement specialists has a minimum of two years in the recruiting industry and an average of nearly 15 years of experience. Each recruiter has their own, personal, and direct experiences within their specialization.

You may expect complete confidentiality at all times during the hiring process; a key element to the success of our business. In today's age we understand that our client's privacy is of the utmost importance.

Contact the Criterion Executive Search office to speak with a recruiter about this job now or find out more about other job placement opportunities.

All applicants applying for U.S. job openings must be authorized to work in the United States. All applicants applying for Canadian job openings must be authorized to work in Canada.

©2026 Criterion Executive Search. An Equal Opportunity Employer. Veteran Owned.


Job Id Number : 11644
Staffing Industry : Insurance
Contact David James in our Tampa, FL office for questions or to apply for the Employee Benefits Client Manager & Department Leader Orlando job today;

INS Insurance
CES CESFL